All bid tipsEvaluation

How evaluators actually read your tender

They don't read it front to back. They score it against a sheet, usually alongside a pile of others. Here's what that means for how you write.

Tessa Facey · 2 min read

Most people write a tender as if someone will read it from the cover to the last appendix, nodding along. That’s not how it happens.

An evaluator sits down with a scoring sheet, a stack of responses and a deadline of their own. They’re looking for the answer to each question, checking it against the criteria, and moving on. Your job is to make that as easy as possible.

They read the question first, then look for your answer

Evaluators usually work question by question across every response, not response by response. So each answer has to stand on its own. If the best part of your answer to question 4 is sitting in your answer to question 2, it probably won’t get counted.

Put the direct answer in the first sentence or two. Then back it up.

They score against the criteria, not against your story

The evaluation criteria and weightings are the closest thing you’ll get to the marking guide. If a question is worth 30% and asks about methodology, risk and resourcing, the evaluator is looking for all three. Miss one and you’ve capped your score, however well the rest is written.

Before you write, map every question to the criteria it’s scored against. Use the client’s own words in your headings so the evaluator can tick things off.

They skim before they score

A wall of text makes an evaluator work harder to find your points. Clear headings, short paragraphs, a table where it helps and evidence placed right next to the claim it supports all make your answer easier to score. Easier to score usually means better scored.

They want proof

“We have a strong safety culture” is a claim. A specific project, what you did and how it turned out is evidence. Evaluators are trained to look for the second one.

For every claim, ask: how would someone who’s never heard of us know this is true?

A quick check before you submit

  • Does every answer lead with the answer?
  • Can you point to where each criterion is covered?
  • Would the evaluator find your evidence without hunting for it?
  • Have you used the client’s language, not just your own?

If you’d like a second pair of eyes on a live tender, book a free 15-minute call.

More bid tips

Got a tender on your desk? Let's make it easy to score.

15 minutes. No prep, no hard sell.

Rather check it yourself first? Run the free go/no-go check